Guest Stars Glenne Headly as Karen Stottlemeyer Misha Collins as Michael Karpov Kerris Dorsey as Little Girl Michael Bower as Peter Robert Clendenin as Gerald Cheryl Hawker as Nurse Nicky Katt as Sgt. Sharkey Zachary Culbertson as Shopper Kitty Swink as Dr. Bradley Scott Conte as Security Guard Rafael Feldman as Detective Pritchert Branden Morgan as Chicklet David Hodges as Suburban Shopper James D. Weston as Doorman Paul Francis Sullivan as Security Guard Reid Harris as Teddy Karpov John Hartmann as Mr. Hoffman