Guest Stars James MacDonald as James Feeney Michelle Trachtenberg as Jodie Keegan-Michael Key as Drew Bret Harrison as Charlie Mo Mandel as Murder Stephen Rannazzisi as Kyle Frances Conroy as Faye Strathmore Merle Dandridge as Krista Kurtwood Smith as Ed Strathmore Jeffrey Tambor as Dr. O Ayda Field as Sapphire Co Starring Mathew Botuchis as Todd Deji LaRay as Beau Taji Coleman as Woman #1 Steve Hasley as Barry Audra Griffis as Jenny Rich Banker as Officer #1