Special Guest Stars Joan Cusack as Sheila Jackson Guest Stars Tyler Jacob Moore as Tony Markovich Madison Davenport as Ethel Joel Murray as Eddie Jackson Amy Smart as Jasmine Hollander Julia Duffy as Candace Lishman Russell Hornsby as Tony's Partner Toby Huss as Steve's Boss Jeremy Ratchford as Detective Bernero Co Starring Michael Patrick McGill as Tommy Frank Pacheco as Joey Milkovich Stacy Hall as Sergeant Steven Lee Allen as Nathan