Special Guest Stars Bethany Joy Lenz as Haley James Scott Kate Voegele as Mia Catalano Guest Stars Ksenia Solo as Natasha "Tasha" Siviac Shaun Sipos as Eric Daniels Emma Caulfield as Emma Bradshaw Austin Butler as Jones Mager Arielle Kebbel as Paige Thomas Cynthia Stevenson as Laverne Cassidy Sarah McLachlan as Herself Ben Lee as Himself Rain Perry as Herself Co Starring Barbara Kottmeier as Suzie Kevin O'Grady as Backstage Guard Reese Alexander as Jail Guard #2 Matt Chamberlain as McLachlan Band Member #3 Simon Cavan Taylor as Concert P.A. Butterfly Boucher as McLachlan Band Member #1 Vince Jones as McLachlan Band Member #2 Peter Stroud as McLachlan Band Member #4