Guest Stars Joe Grifasi as Judge Arlen Rand Sarah Steele as Ellen Huff Adriana DeGirolami as Gina Celeste Arias as Reese Tiffany Villarin as Amanda Toll Co Starring James Boland as Freddie Anja Jai as Jessica Tiffany Robinson as Mirror Agatha James Tam as Mirror Sydney Matt Lipton as Christopher Kim Exum as Agatha Alex Ashrafi as Mirror Christopher Divya Sethi as Mirror Jessica Lilli Cooper as Claudia William Chang as Sydney Bill Vila as Mock Juror #1 Charles Bendes as Peter Dacyl Acevedo as Angela Nell Balaban as Mock Juror #3 Cilda Shaur as Mock Juror #2 Alex Breaux as Rob McKellan Gabriel Awan as Court Officer James Kautz as Mirror Wade Joshua Alscher as Wade Miller Amelia Fowler as Amy, Jury Foreman Matt Wall as Reporter #1 Teresa Woods as Reporter #2
