Guest Stars Jerry O'Connell as Detective Woodrow "Woody" Hoyt Emy Coligado as Emmy Arija Bareikis as Detective Annie Capra Anthony DeSando as Father Paul Tomas Arana as Father Bruno Casnelli Robin Riker as Frances Pritchard Lenny Citrano as Leonard Lenny Wolpe as Ronald Cosgrove Co Starring Louis Iacoviello as Uniformed Cop Baadja-Lyne Odums as Landlady Nicholas Shaffer as Tech Jacob Bruce as Jeffeson