Guest Stars David Ogden Stiers as Reverend Eugene "Gene" Purdy Bill Mondy as Deputy Roscoe Kristen Dalton as Dana Bright Shaun Johnston as Terry Collier Nicki Clyne as Erin Salkowe Lesley Ewen as Mrs. Maggie Tyner Colby Johannson as Tom Hirsch Angelo Renai as Eli Bill Switzer as Doug Hirsch Zook Matthews as Edgar Sharmin Mackay as Kate Tyner