Guest Stars Aunjanue Ellis as Madeleine Hightower Michael Gaston as Gale Bertram Pruitt Taylor Vince as J.J. LaRoche Rebecca Wisocky as Brenda Shettrick Eric Winter as Craig O'Laughlin Mekia Cox as Tracy Zuniga Jesse Lee Soffer as Alan Dinkler Adam Kulbersh as Drake Vermilion Ravi Kapoor as Anthony Gupta Co Starring Tyler R. Brooks as Deputy Meyers Carl Ciarfalio as Officer #1 Carla Barnett as Female Customer Nick Hanneman as Officer #2