Guest Stars Betty Gilpin as Nancy Leveau Jeremy Strong as Art Dreesen Sarah Silverman as Helen Schiff David Walton as Bram Keller Nick Clifford as Guy Danny Jacobs as Bob Drag Niecy Nash as Louise Bell Rondi Reed as Edith Schiff Charles Shaughnessy as Mr. Clavermore Joel Brooks as Mr. Schiff Lisa Banes as Mrs. Clavermore Jonathan Adams as Judge Varga Matt McCoy as Arnold Ketterman Donald Sage MacKay as Prosecutor John Watson Beth Kennedy as Potential Juror #11 Tom Kiesche as Jerry Co Starring Caiden Milick as Howie Masters Robert Arce as Juror #24 Blair Fraser as Juror #31 James Liebman as Professor/Juror #22 Joey Vahedi as Literary Man Hiep Thi Le as Juror #14 Nancy Clemons as Secretary