Guest Stars H. Jon Benjamin voices Jimmy Pesto Jr. Andy Kindler voices Mort Brian Huskey voices Regular Sized Rudy Sarah Silverman voices Ollie Laura Silverman voices Andy Jay Johnston voices Jimmy Pesto Laura Silverman voices Mother Sarah Silverman voices Maid H. Jon Benjamin voices Umpire Rob Huebel voices The Deuce Jason Mantzoukas voices Mr. Manoogian David Herman voices Coach Kurt Braunohler voices Vagrant