Special Guest Stars Gary Cole as Kurt McVeigh Guest Stars Chris Butler as Matan Brody David Paymer as Judge Richard Cuesta James Carpinello as Detective Anthony Burton Tom Pelphrey as Josh Mundy Tovah Feldshuh as Lena Selenis Leyva as Marisol Kelli Barrett as Bianca Price Jeff McCarthy as Mitch Christopher Evan Welch as Dr. Miner Co Starring Jeanine Serralles as Sarah James Monroe Iglehart as Geo Ella Rae Peck as Jenny Bauer John Behlmann as Dr. Mann David Ross as Coach Lawton Ben Jeffrey as Juror #7 Chandra Thomas as Juror #12 Joel Hatch as Juror #8 Robin LeMon as Juror #11 Steve Jean-Baptiste as Juror #9 Tony Torn as Professor Dunn Andy Powers as Reporter Kate Levy as Juror #10 Leslie Denniston as Mrs. Price