Guest Stars Ruth Connell as Rowena MacLeod Rob Benedict as Chuck Shurley / God Emily Swallow as Amara Keith Szarabajka as Professor Donatello Redfield Barbara Eve Harris as Clea Co Starring Lee Shorten as Minion #1 Rami Kahlon as Angel #1 Ese Atawo as Witch #4 Mackenzie Murdock as Giggling Demon Joel Cottingham as Angel #2 Cori Woods as Witch #3 Melissa M. Montgomery as Witch #2