Special Guest Stars Faith Prince as Elaine Bingum Guest Stars Ben Feldman as Fred Mike Pniewski as Amos Hanson David Denman as Tony Nicastro Clayton Landey as Judge Andrew Brody Ashley LeConte Campbell as Rhonda Grant Veda Wilson as Judge Austen Jenny O'Hara as Carla Shane Ray Wise as Frank Dodd Nia Vardalos as Lisa Shane Jordan Woods-Robinson as Perry Detweiller Rus Blackwell as Max Strickland Catherine Dyer as Sally Dodd