Special Guest Stars Taye Diggs as Jackson Duper Guest Stars Albert Hall as Judge Seymore Walsh John Michael Higgins as Attorney Steven Milter Bernadette Peters as Cassandra Lewis Meta Golding as Sylvie Stiles Ann Cusack as Rebecca Moore Arturo Gil as Douglas McGrath David Batiste as Michael Pupnick Co Starring Renée Elise Goldsberry as Singer Vatrena King as Singer Sy Smith as Singer Gwendolyn Oliver as Foreperson Uncredited Greg Bronson as Janitor