Guest Stars Marisa Coughlan as Melissa Hughes Shelley Berman as Judge Robert Sanders Ron Canada as Judge Willard Reese Ashley Rios as Fiona Lewiston April Rios as Fiona Lewiston Jayne Brook as Rachel Lewiston Scott Paulin as U.S. Attorney Jonathan Shapiro Josh Braaten as Scott Warner Bradley James as Marshall Thomas Leahy Robert Joseph as Marshall Joseph Reynolds Michael Hilow as P.I. Jerome Brad Bovee as P.I. Smollers