Special Guest Stars David Strathairn as Patrick Kloster Guest Stars Emmy Clarke as Julie Teeger Evan Peters as Eric Tavala Elena Evangelo as Linda Kloster Lawrence O'Donnell as Judge Lawrence Barr Federico Dordei as Michael the Cook Co Starring Susan Larkin as Paulina Jimmy Pardo as Association President Dona Hardy as First Elderly Woman Darren Capozzi as First Detective Betty Murphy as 2nd Elderly Woman Paul Lieber as Medical Examiner Elise Baughman as Reporter