Guest Stars Bill Oberst Jr. as Unsub Adrienne Barbeau as Cissy Howard Tobin Bell as Malachi Lee Ronnie Gene Blevins as Miles Lee Gregory Sporleder as Sam Caplan Co Starring Will Green as Brent DeDe Drake as Sandy Stephanie C. Allen as Teenage Cissy Burt Culver as Clark Howard Rocky McMurray as Captain Rogers Ben Adams as Teen Malachi Castille Landon as Maddie Lee Cedrick Hardman as Unsub Hand Double Wednezday Ryan as Appalachian Woman