Special Guest Stars Dean Winters as Dennis Duffy James Marsden as Criss Chros Guest Stars Kristen Schaal as Hazel Wassername Al Roker as Himself Ira Glass voices Ira Glass Co Starring Sue Galloway as Sue LaRoche-Van der Hout Melissa McMeekin as Megan Duffy Matthew Porter as Floor Manager Brandon James Ellis as Drunk Guy Uncredited Shane Tunney as Puker