Guest Stars Andy Karl as Sergeant Mike Dodds Robert Sean Leonard as Assistant D.A. Kenneth O'Dwyer Michael Gaston as Coach Donald Basinski Alberto Rosende as Jordan Massina Jordan Gelber as Principal Bernstein Kelli Barrett as Phoebe Burnap Ted Sutherland as Zach Foster Noah Fleiss as Nat Dennehy Missy Crider as Serena Foster Erik Heger as Cole Foster Co Starring Tony Campisi as Counselor Steve Roth Mark D. Friedman as Counselor Roger Parnes Kate Elizabeth Young as Melora Ngozi Anyanwu as Officer Perlina Edozi Lindsay Arnold as Megan Alex Esola as David Faulkner Shanga Parker as Doctor Brett G. Smith as State Trooper Al Clark Jeanine Pirro as Herself Christopher Gray as Travis Barstow Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration
