Guest Stars Aalok Mehta as Barnaby Anne Beyer as Shula Alessandro Colla as Jairus Philip Shahbaz as Rabbi Akiva Jorge Franco IV as David Rafael Petardi as TBD Karim Sioud as TBD Co Starring Nina Leon as Mary Salome Damon Carney as Julius Steve Shermett as Rabbi Josiah Lowell Byers as Jed Nene Nwoko as Rivka Joe Nemmers as Clerk Moriah Smallbone as Bathsheva Jay Santiago as Father of Uzziah Paul Diaz as Crivle Abdul Ayoola as TBD Nikki Dixon as TBD Ryan Radis as Uzziah Juan Carlos Díaz as TBD Federica Rangel as Mother of Uzziah