Guest Stars Jason Mantzoukas as Preacher Co Starring Anthony Mackie Jr. as Young John Jeronimo Spinx as Driving Holy Man Dennis Keiffer as Drunk Holy Man Ned Yousef as Holy Mechanic Sharon Landry as Wandering Woman Sean Braud as Hatchet Holy Man Alex Aschinger as Jeffrey James Cusimano as Holy Cupbearer Lena Clark as Goddess Janice Kevin Reid as Gunshot Holy Man Av Ayoung as Thirsty Holy Man Aaron D. Parker as Moaning Cross Man