Guest Stars Scott Porter as Orson Adam Kaplan as Chad Michael Benz as Kevin Ayumi Patterson as Marta George Hampe as Ned Co Starring Annabelle Wachtel as Young Lindsay Scott Turner Schofield as Phil Tanairi Vazquez as 'What If" Dancer Christopher Ralph as 'What If" Dancer Alex Wong as 'What If" Dancer Christopher Hernandez as 'What If" Dancer Jenna Ho as 'What If" Dancer Terk Lewis as 'What If" Dancer Eliza Ohman as 'What If" Dancer Ryan Redmond as 'What If" Dancer Chelsea Thedinga as 'What If" Dancer