Special Guest Stars Margo Martindale as Senator Elizabeth Guthrie Guest Stars Amy Landecker as Nancy Costello Tony Curran as Frankie Cullen Moss as Rudy Cunningham Chet Hanks as Joey Maldini Ciara Renée as Janelle Williams Mark Margolis as Carmine Conti Mark O'Brien as Father Jay James Vincent Meredith as Kenneth Robert Pralgo as Phillip Calabri Arthur Nascarella as Sal Calabri Mason Beauchamp as KJ Co Starring Kelvin Witherspoon as Russell Gavin "Chief" Meredith as Chris Jessica Toltzis as Angela Robert Aberdeen as Max Jasmine Shanise as Clarice Javian JB Brown as Terrance Jakobe Dehon Brownlee as Jordan Tyler Richardson as Leroy Byron Clohessy as NOPD Officer