Guest Stars Robert Patrick as Sheriff McDowell Marley Shelton as Emma Dutton Jennifer Ehle as Sister Mary Leenah Robinson as Baapuxti Kerry O'Malley as Sister Alice Jessalyn Gilsig as Beverly Strafford Co Starring Caleb Martin as Dennis Brian Konowal as Clive Dakota Ogden as Carl Brian Brown as Jasper Jeff Leaf as Charles Brewster Colt Brown as Alec (Sheeper) Tyler Gaisford as Horace Grant Bradley Fisher as Clive Hoburn Craig Clyde as Rancher Tim Mikulecky as Sergeant KC Coy as Soldier Cooper Taylor as Spade