Guest Stars Derek Rivera as Santiago Reyes Martin Bobb-Semple as Orlando 'Lando' Johnson Joe Holt as Jesse Raymond Heather Harris as Gabrielle Sabrina Revelle as Coach Elaine Loni Greta Onieogou as Layla Keating Naomi Baker as Nessa Co Starring Kandiss Crone as Lillie Arnold Ted Jonas as Umpire #1 Ciarra Carter as Riva Ducane