Special Guest Stars Chris Sullivan as Paul Serra Guest Stars Constance Zimmer as Anna Harvey Derrick Delgado as Danny Serra Ben Shenkman as Rabbi Cermak Danielle Davenport as Marcie Holt Rafael Cebrián as Brad Holt Arielle Duran as Sarah Sowinsky Co Starring Sandy Hernandez as Elisabeth Serra Liam Delgado as Eric Serra Ben Graney as Young Avraham's Father Quinlan Kelleher as Young Avraham Don Ackerman as Eddie Williams Johnny Bermudez as ESU Lieutenant Aerina DeBoer as Crying Child #1