Guest Stars Betti as Travis Sierra Katow as Evangeline Hashima Isabella Roland as Carla Cheyenne Perez as Jo Scott Lipman as Frude Maya Rose Berko as Jena Rob Huebel as Henry Murray Nicole Sullivan as Carol Finkle Spencer Neville as Aaron Craig Cackowski as Dale Finkle Colton Tran as Theta Bro Ally Ioannides as Sara Jamie Denbo as Loan Officer Rachel Leah Cohen as Water Polo Coach Co Starring Caleb Lowell as Finn Yasmin Kassim as Jessica William Prescott as Host Garrett Westton as Alex Rachel Winfree as Coach's Assistant Min Hwa Cho as Water Polo Girl Blake Mallegni as Student