Guest Stars Austin Stowell as Pete Welsh Joe Chrest as Bishop Matthew Paulse Meg Steedle as Sherry Bonita Friedericy as Sister Ramona Bruce McKinnon as Roger Flynn Ella Jay Basco as Sofia Nyaling Marenah as Sister Margaret Co Starring Norah Murphy as Older Susan Broberg Steven Sean Garland as Agent Richard McDaniel Ava Grace Roberts as Nicole Paulsen Ava Leigh as Carly Landry Townsend as Rita Kelly Liz McGeever as Janice Welsh Phil Biedron as Guard Penny Munroe as Jennifer Welsh Carlie Wescott as Lorrie
