Guest Stars Bridget Regan as Rockin' Roxy Andrea Londo as Betty Donelon Tyler Lofton as Tony Co Starring Anthony S. Goolsby as Derek Fisher Martin Bradford as Troy Ryan Reilly as Gordon Baxter Jophielle Love as 5 Year Old Mary Anabelle Holloway as 10 Year Old Mary Jackie Dallas as Patty Erickson Uncredited Jensen Ackles voices Dean Winchester
