Special Guest Stars Haylie Duff as Stevie Marx Guest Stars Mageina Tovah as Glynis Figliola Mark Totty as Det. Carlisle Sonya Eddy as Female Custodian God Nancy Lenehan as Erica Marx Vanessa Bell Calloway as Corey Phillips Kate Norby as Dr. Jennifer Davis Jack Kehler as Electrician God Edward Edwards as Charlie Marx Nikki Tyler-Flynn as Glynis' Mom Al Mancini as Grandpa God Co Starring Sarah Lilly as Nora Harry Hayman as Boy Scout God