Guest Stars Matt Dellapina as Eric Rentzel Stephanie Ittleson as Judge Rogers Diany Rodriguez as Ada O'Neill Daniel Cosgrove as AUSA Walt Carto Sasha Diamond as Kelsey / Agent Steadman A.J. Shively as Jerry McConnell Jamie Ragusa as Clara Co Starring Ollie Robinson as Mauricio Rentzel Brandi Wilson as Juror 14 / Bonnie R.J. Foster as FBI Agent Bowen RJ Vaillancourt as Juror 1 Tanya Everett as Juror 2 Cassandra Cruz as Juror 3 John Marcionetti as Juror 4