Guest Stars Brandon Scott Jones as Curtis Paltrow Tuc Watkins as Troy Adam David Thompson as Pastor Jax Dag Frank De Julio as DC Lawyer Blake Baumgartner as Young Brooke Co Starring Joe Curnutte as Dan Caleb Reese Paul as Young Cary George Deihl Jr. as Producer Liz Priestley as Tourist #1 Geraldine Leer as Leanne Steve Blanchard as Priest Christopher Chan as Bruce Alex Boniello as Indie Rock Band Singer Natalie Leer Walker as Seinfeld Joe Castle Baker as Vincent Suzen Baraka as Beth Tommy Do as Tony Mary Kate Moore as Lou Winslow Bright as Jagger