Guest Stars Amir Talai as Joe Lisa Rinna as Herself Allan Wasserman as Rabbi Sherman Lindsey Kraft as Deborah Jack Laufer as Mr. Abelman Co Starring Gable Swanlund as Nancy Lee Bachrach as Lizzie Bob Glouberman as Herb Kesia Brooke as Tracey Justin James Farley as Marty's Teammate #2 Jean Glaudé as Jerry, Elderly Man Larry Weissman as Benjamin Alixandrée Antoine as Ashley, Decked Out Party Guest Marco Antonio Parra as Marty's Teammate #1