Guest Stars Lauren Lapkus as Agent Phoebe Donnegan Jonathan Silverman as Dave Shane Coffey as Kevin Breckin Meyer as Vance Madison Ignacio Serricchio as Nick Martin Erin Cummings as Tina Madison Adam Cropper as Scott Co Starring Archer Moller as Garett Shannon Dee as Becca Rhomeyn Johnson as Clark David Alen as Elderly Man