Guest Stars Lena Georgas as Janet Ravis Holley Fain as Evelyn Crowley Missi Pyle as Karen Kintner Lily Donoghue as Tracy Broderick Anna Jacoby-Heron as Jenny Broderick Emily Bergl as Marie Stewart Cameron Crovetti as Ryan Broderick Miles Emmons as Anthony Broderick Joelle Carter as Yvonne Newsome Tiera Skovbye as Young Betty Vanessa Martinez as Celia Chris Mason as Young Dan Doug Savant as Martin Newsome Greg Cromer as Preston Dunbar Michael Monks as Professor Mather Zickel as TBD Co Starring Scarlett Abinante as Young Tracy Tom Virtue as Father David Caleb Ruminer as Nick Dan Warner as Henry John Brytnee Ratledge as Amy Trevor Black as Mitch Gilman Eric Staves as Drew