Guest Stars Sachin Sahel as Eric Jackson Adina Porter as Indra Luisa d'Oliveira as Emori Lola Flanery as Madi Ivana Miličević as Charmaine Diyoza Lee Majdoub as Nelson / Sachin Jason Diaz as Levitt Alaina Huffman as Nikki Neal McDonough as First Disciple Anders Co Starring Luc Roderique as Penn Adam Lolacher as Jeremiah Xavier de Guzman as Knight Sean Quan as Rex Miles Chalmers as Zev Britt Irvin as Alyssa Alex Barima as Kwame Leah Hennessey as Luca's Mother Orla Eileen Oliver-Jay as Baby Hope Saoirse Kenzie Oliver-Jay as Baby Hope Chris Bradford as Luca's Father Julie Lynn Mortensen as Miss Haggerman Vera Ann Frederickson as Kim Grace Sunar as Student #4 Mat Lo as Nurse Disciple Marcello Guedes as Sean Logan McInnes as Student #5 Isla Sunar as Student #3