Special Guest Stars James Marsden as Phil Crane Guest Stars Ben Rosenfield as John Schlafly Cindy Drummond as Lottie Beth Hobbs Andrea Navedo as Carmen Delgado Votaw Co Starring Julia Lalonde as Anne Schlafly Ethan Hektor as Andy Schlafly Brendan Cox as Bruce Schlafly Marcia Bennett as Dadie Stewart Olivia Scriven as Phyl/Liza Schlafly Melissa Joyner as Audrey Rowe Colom Novie Edwards as Willie B. Reed Jordan Kenny as Roger Schlafly Carly Sztern as Kathleen Marium Carvell as Leonia Brian O'Neill as Jesse Helms Andrea Grant as Arlene Crane David Eisner as Martin Abzug Brendan Halloran as John Sears David Snelgrove as Buck Macray Billy Parrott as Gala Starstruck Supporter's Husband Marisa McIntyre as Female Test Taker / Reporter Daniel Beirne as Hamilton Jordan Amélie Albert-LeBlanc as Commission Support Staff #1 Alex Gravenstein as Roger Stone Danielle Height as Commission Support Staff #2 Greg Campbell as White House Counsel Danielle Bourgon as Gala Starstruck Supporter #1 Kent Sheridan as Handsome Stranger David Barrett as Cab Driver Jacqueline LaFayette as Commission Support Staff #3 Brandon James Sim as Paul Manafort Adam Nicholas Smith as Hotel Security Guard #1 / Gala Drew Tyce as White House Aide