Guest Stars Anne Hathaway as Lexi Donohoe Gary Carr as Jeff Quincy Tyler Bernstine as Sylvia Judd Hirsch as Harry the Cabby Judd Hirsch as Alec the Vendor Judd Hirsch as Officer Mahoney Savvy Crawford as Young Lexi Jane Beaird as Adolescent Lexi Delaney Moro as Roommate Daphne Zelle as Waitress