Guest Stars Zibby Allen as Julie Seth Rogen as Adam Wegman / Seth Zazie Beetz as Sophie Gelson Betty Gabriel as Betty Caitlin Stryker as Anna Co Starring Mark Silverman voices Rod Serling (Voice) Jason Priestley as Jason Priestley Carlena Britch as Charlie Camille Hollett-French as Amy Matthew Mandzij voices Father Byron Noble as Owen Ryan Hesp as Rod Serling (Face) Deni DeLory as Librarian David Epstein as Blurryman Al McFoster as 1st AD Jefferson Black as Rod Serling (Body) Takaya White as Young Sophie Romy Cutler-Lengyel voices Mother Vanessa Zwez Lindgren as Sitcom Cast #6