Guest Stars Maggie Grace as Hannah Cottrell Cheryl White as Elizabeth Cottrell Sam Anderson as Martin Morgan-Bryant Kathryn Harrold as Mrs. Morgan-Bryant Co Starring Alex Villiers as Matty Santos Michael Len as Young Paul James Lashly as Caleb Brandis Kemp as Miriam Scott N. Stevens as Doctor Neal Dodson as Josiah Laura Romine as Young Hannah Taylor Litchfield as Emma