Guest Stars Caitlin Mehner as Heather Husband Candice Coke as Wren Tiffany Dupont as Nikki Castro Jeffrey Nordling as Rick Zahn Heidi Johanningmeier as Linda Barrett Elaine Hendrix as Susan Alders Jennifer Parsons as Helen Scott Josh Clark as Jack Scott Co Starring Casey Tutton as Rosemary Lynch James Farruggio as ASA Duncan Ricky J. Hawk as Nathan Grace Fahey as Young Heather Jennifer Estlin as Judge Cohen Seb Torgus as Young Toby Kissell Maggie Scrantom as Sarah Tawney Isabel Kaegi as Young Sarah Sharyon Culberson as Foreperson Danny Farber as Manager Krystel McNeil as Joan Myers Manny Buckley as Assistant Medical Examiner Sayjal Joshi as Drone Operator Loretta Rezos as Zoe Madison Mary Moreira as Elderly Mother Dave Perez as Elderly Father