Guest Stars Royce Johnson as Detective Sergeant Brett Mahoney Annette O'Toole as Eliza Schultz Corbin Bernsen as Anderson Schultz Teri Reeves as Marlena Olin Allie McCulloch as Rebecca Pilgrim Henry Boshart as Lemuel Pilgrim Zell Steele Morrow as Michael Pilgrim Joe Holt as Sheriff Roy Hardin Michael Pemberton as Lieutenant Ferrara Rudy Eisenzopf as Deputy Dobbs Jamie Ann Romero as Deputy Murphy Ramona Floyd as Doctor Evans Brandon Gill as Deputy Ken Ogden Donald Webber, Jr. as Bruce Ogden Wilbur Edwin Henry as Reverend Potter Alex Pires as IT Guy Charles Romanelli as Militia