Guest Stars Nicholas Holmes as Joel Hynek Robert John Burke as William Fairchild Heather Doerksen as Donna Smith Steven Williams as Nathan Tony Alcantar as Professor Carlton Fanshaw Adam Greydon Reid as Donald Keyhoe Co Starring Stephanie Bennett as Leigh-Ann Chris Shields as Byron Craig March as Andy Francesca Bianchi as Gina Gaalen Engen as Salesman Colin Murdock as Radio Host Chris Robson as Middle-Aged Man Chad Rook as Rudy Pitts David Coakley as Staff Sergeant Weeks Joshua Hinkson as Richard Elyse Maloway as Student #1 Deborah Trotchine as Student #3 Justin Stone as Skip Sebastian Greaves as Charlie Shauna Hansen as Woman Jesse Irving as Tom Wilson Don McLeod as Arnold Peter Skagen as Sheriff