Guest Stars Kurt Fuller as Judge Peter Dunaway Ian Unterman as Joel Kingsley-Weaver Aya Cash as Amber Audrey Dorian Missick as Brett Tatro Crystal Dickinson as Josie Tatro Salvatore Inzerillo as Evan Houston Graham Winton as Det. Richard Hardy John Quilty as Mr. Cottonback Lucy Owen as Daktoa Timothy D. Stickney as Daniel Cain Josiah Bania as Jeff Garrix