Guest Stars Amy Sedaris as Mimi Kanassis Elise Mestichelli as C.H.E.R.Y./L. Noah Robbins as Zach Todd Buonopane as Gabe James Hosey as Tyler Greg Kinnear as Greg Kinnear Zachary Quinto as Eli Rubin Paul Walter Hauser as Tripp Knob Martino Caputo as City Worker Peyton Lusk as Oliver Norm Lewis as Rumbleshanks Dylan Price as Young Nerd Sarah Uriarte Berry as St. Jellorica Lynn Masako Cheng as Young Tourist