Guest Stars Yara Martinez as Isabella Colón Victor Williams as AUSA Rosenberg Stephanie Ittleson as Judge Rogers Abbi Snee as Grace Fisher Frank De Julio as Elliot Miles Amy Staats as Molly O'Neil Murphy Guyer as Dr. Thiessen Reyna de Courcy as Lily Galloway Co Starring Vincent Ingrisano as Jury Foreman Gregory Konow as Officer on Duty Robert McKay as Chief Denton Teddy Coluca as Potential Juror #3 Jon Shaver as Fire Chief Mario Corry as Kevin Webster Yaron Urbas as Coroner Cherie Mendez as Potential Juror #5 Raheem Brock as Guard Mark Maciejewski as Potential Juror #1 Megan McGarvey as Potential Juror #2