Guest Stars Usman Ally as Hook-Handed Man Matty Cardarople as Henchperson of Indetermined Gender Nathan Fillion as Jacques Snicket Sara Canning as Jacquelyn Patrick Breen as Larry Your-Waiter Sara Rue as Olivia Caliban Cleo King as Eleanora Poe Tony Hale as Jerome Squalor Co Starring Tara Strong voices Sunny Baudelaire Joyce Robbins as White Faced Woman #2 Jacqueline Robbins as White Faced Woman #1 John DeSantis as Bald Man Marion Eisman as Auction Attendee Morgan Brayton as Auction Attendee Craig Erickson as Auction Attendee Sage Brocklebank as Doorperson Marco Grazzini as Chauffeur (Abraham)