Guest Stars Amanda Leighton as Emma Kurtzman Jordan Rodrigues as Mat Tan Alex Saxon as Wyatt Casey Meg DeLacy as Grace Mullen Lisseth Chavez as Ximena Sinfuego Madisen Beaty as Talya Banks Nandy Martin as Poppy Sinfuego Michael Traynor as Craig Nia Peeples as Susan Mullen Kristen Ariza as Tess Bayfield Reggie Austin as Dean Bayfield Suzanne Cryer as Jenna Paul Anna Grace Barlow as Zoey Nick Fink as Shawn Chris McGarry as Agent Allen Jean Louisa Kelly as Pastor Nicole Co Starring Scott Broderick as Agent Estes / ICE Agent #1 Chelsea Rendon as Social Worker / Lisa Cameron McKendry as Josh Marlon Aquino as Waiter Thomas Crawford as Judge Justin Tinucci as Senior