Guest Stars Sprague Grayden as Carrie Cooke Felix Solis as Agent Jeffrey Clarke Shane McRae as Robert Mackenzie Marsh as Tilda Tom Cavanagh as Kingston Tanner Carter Jenkins as Preston Tanner Connor Fox as Jason Liza de Weerd as Angela Ezra Knight as Roman Geoffrey Cantor as Detective Co Starring Nicole Sellars as News Reporter Adam Donshik as Marshal Doyle DeShawn Harold Mitchell as NYPD Officer Walter Hudson as Father McManus Isabel Shill as Karyn