Guest Stars Kerry Condon as Dr. Zoe Boyle Trieste Kelly Dunn as FBI Special Agent Elizabeth Ferrell Ato Essandoh as FBI Agent Garner Matthew Rauch as FBI Agent Martin Peter McRobbie as FBI Director Lofton Juri Henley-Cohn as Luke Hayden Tom Lipinski as Matt Railsback Dan Bittner as Katherine's Fiancee Suzy Jane Hunt as Katherine Zalben Co Starring Katie McClellan as Lila Leeds Rob Morgan as Joshua Carpenter Rey Lucas as Bill Nick Blaemire as Gore Marc Webster as NYPD Supervisor Arthur Gerunda as Gerald Nikolas Kontomanolis as Street Vendor Ruben Ortiz as Elementary Father Mike Ganim as Cab Driver